Keyword Cannibalization: How to Identify and Fix It [4 Ways]

Keyword cannibalization can happen on any website, no matter the size or amount of content.

It can be an issue because it can negatively influence your search engine positions.

This post will discuss what is, how it may impact your rankings, and how to identify and fix it!

What Is Keyword Cannibalization?

Keyword cannibalization is when you have multiple pages on your website that are competing for the same keyword.

This can happen unintentionally if you have similar pages or if you use the same term multiple times on different pages.

It can hurt your website because it confuses search engines. They don’t know which page to rank for the keyword, so they may not rank any of them.

For example, let’s say you have two pages about “SEO strategies”.

Optimizing both pages on the same term means you’re keyword cannibalizing (for example, “SEO tips”, “SEO strategies”, or “SEO techniques”). And it can be an issue because it can impact each page’s ability to rank well in search engines.

Keyword cannibalization can also happen on a smaller scale.

For example, you may have a page about “link building” and another page about “link building strategies“.

If you are focusing on the term “link building” on both pages, then you’re probably keyword cannibalizing.

How Keyword Cannibalization Impacts Your SEO

Keyword cannibalization is bad, but it’s important to point out that you have a real issue only when you have several pages targeting the same keyword.

Considering that pages can rank for many terms, it may not be the case.

In fact, according to a study by Ahrefs, pages that rank in the top 10 for one keyword typically rank for hundreds of other ones:

This SEO statistic tells us that it’s important to focus on writing about topics, not just single terms.

For example, let’s say that you have two pages created around the term “on-page SEO“.

One of them ranks in the top positions, while the other one is not. You could blame keyword cannibalization because the first page is stealing organic traffic from the second one.

Now, even if it’s true that you are not getting traffic for that specific term, both pages can rank for hundreds of other ones!

And if you could decide to combine the two pages into a big one, you could potentially lose some of the keywords you were previously ranking for (and see a drop in organic traffic).

In general, keyword cannibalization can impact your website’s SEO in a few different ways:

• It can split up your link equity: If you have multiple pages that are keyword cannibalizing, then the link equity (i.e. the power of your links) will be split between those pages instead of going to just one page.
• It can dilute your keyword rankings: If you’re keyword cannibalizing, then it’s likely that only one of your pages will rank for that term. The other page(s) will struggle to rank because they’re competing with a similar page on your site.
• It can confuse search engines: If you have multiple pages targeting the same words, then it can be difficult for search engines to understand which page is most relevant for that keyword. This can impact your rankings and click-through rates.

Keyword Cannibalization Examples

Here are some of the most common keyword cannibalization situations:

• URLs That Keep Changing Rankings
• Ranking Keywords Fail to Increase
• URL That You Don’t Want Are Ranking

URLs That Keep Changing Rankings

You may have keyword cannibalization if your URLs keep changing rankings.

This happens when Google cannot figure out which URL should rank for a term.

And it can be an issue because it can make your website appear unstable to Google and may impact user experience, including your click-through rates.

Two years ago Google’s John Mueller made an AMA on Reddit and someone asked about keyword cannibalization:

And the final comment was:

Write for your audience, how they would search, and how they digest content. There’s no word-count necessary, no keyword density needed.

Ranking Keywords Fail to Increase

If your rankings fail to increase, then it may be caused that you are targeting many similar terms.

This happens when you have multiple pages that are keyword cannibalizing and the authority of the pages is splitting the link equity.

As a result, your rankings stay the same or may even drop.

URL That You Don’t Want Are Ranking

Have you ever noticed that a wrong URL ranks for a certain keyword?

For example, a product ranks for a term that you want your category page to rank for.

This happens when you have keyword cannibalization and search engines are confused about which page is most relevant for that term.

How to Identify Keyword Cannibalization

To identify it, you need to understand what the searcher is looking for and match it with the right content.

If multiple pages are targeting the same keywords but NOT the same intent, then it’s not a keyword cannibalization issue.

But when the intent is the same for specific pages, then you are basically competing against yourself.

Here are some free ways to find these pages:

• Site: Search Operator
• Google Search Console
• Ahrefs

Site: Search Operator

One of the easiest ways to find keyword cannibalization issues is to use the site: search operator.

Just type in “site:[yourdomain.com]+keyword” into Google and it will show you all the pages from your website that are ranking for that term.

From there, you can analyze the pages to see if they are keyword cannibalizing.

For example, if we type:

We can see that Moz.com actually has cannibalization issues.

Google Search Console

Another way to find keyword cannibalization issues is to use Google Search Console.

Just go to the “Performance Report” > “Pages”.

Here, you can see which pages are ranking for the same term, by clicking on each of the keywords your website is ranking for.

Ahrefs

Ahrefs is a paid keyword research tool that also has a feature to find keyword cannibalization issues.

Just go to “Site Explorer” > “Organic Keywords” and toggle “Multiple URLs only”

Ahrefs will show you all the pages that are ranking for the same term.

For example, let’s run a search for Moz.com:

As you can see, Site Explorer found the same issue for the term “keyword cannibalization” as it was identified earlier using method #1.

How to Fix Keyword Cannibalization

Here are some of the most common ways to fix the problem:

• Consolidate
• Noindex Tags
• Redirects
• Canonical Tags

Consolidate

This is the most common and used practice to solve the issue.

Basically, you want to take all the keyword-cannibalizing pages and combine them into one single page.

For example, if you have two pages that are keyword cannibalizing, you want to take the content from both pages and put it into one.

You can then redirect the other page to the one that you want to rank.

Doing this will help Google understand which page is most relevant for the term and should be ranked.

Noindex Tags

Another way to fix the issue is to use a “noindex” tag (this gives instructions to Google not to index a page).

This is useful if you have pages that are keyword cannibalizing but you don’t want them to rank.

All you need to do is add a meta robots noindex tag to those pages and Google will stop indexing them.

Redirects

Another way is by using redirects, which can be used to send users from one URL to another.

This is useful if you have pages that are keyword cannibalizing but you want to redirect the traffic to another page.

For example, you may want to send visitors from a product page to your category page.

All you need to do is add a 301 redirect from the old URL to the new URL and Google will start sending users from the old URL to the new one.

Canonical Tags

A canonical tag is an HTML tag that tells Google which version of a webpage is the original.

This is useful if you have pages that are keyword cannibalizing but you want Google to index only one of them.

All you need to do is add a canonical tag to the pages that you want Google to index and Google will start indexing only those pages.

Keyword Cannibalization FAQs

Q: Are Keyword stuffing and keyword cannibalization the same?

No, keyword stuffing and keyword cannibalization are not the same.

The first is when you have too many keywords on a page which can negatively impact your rankings.

The second happens when multiple pages are competing for the same term and none of them can rank high because they are splitting the link equity between them.

Q: What is keyword clustering?

Keyword clustering is a technique used to group similar keywords together. It helps you create content that can target multiple related search terms without keyword cannibalizing each other.

For example, if you have the term “vegan restaurants”, you might also cluster it with related words like “vegan food”, “vegetarian restaurants” and “vegan restaurants near me”.

By using this technique, you can ensure that your content is targeting related search terms without competing against itself.

Q: Can keyword cannibalization lead to a penalty?

No, keyword cannibalization does not lead to a penalty. However, it can cause your rankings to drop if multiple pages are targeting the same terms.

When this happens, Google won’t be able to decide which page is most relevant for that term, so it will end up ranking neither of them.

Therefore, it’s important to identify and fix this kind of issue as soon as possible in order to maximize your rankings.

Q: What is an example of keyword cannibalization?

An example of keyword cannibalization is if you have multiple pages on your website targeting the same keyword, such as “weight loss diet” and each page has different content. In this case, Google won’t be able to decide which page is most relevant for that term so it won’t rank any of them.

To fix this issue, you can either consolidate the pages into one page and redirect the other to it, or use noindex tags, canonical tags, or 301 redirects to prevent them from competing against each other.

Before You Go

Now that you have learned more about how to avoid targeting similar keywords, it’s time to get more traffic!

Be sure to check these posts:

What do you think?

If you have any questions, feel free to leave a comment below.

I’ll be happy to help!

 

Related Reading:

• Dwell Time in SEO: The Complete Guide
• Bounce Rate: What Is and How to Improve It [8 Tips]
• Keyword Golden Ratio: How to Rank Fast on Google with KGR
• Crawl Budget: The Ultimate Reference Guide
• Orphan Pages: Finding and Fixing Them [Quick Guide]